This family-friendly eatery churns out hundreds of lobster rolls on a daily basis that served with their creamy cole slaw. Apparently Perry Duryea Sr. bought the place, a boathouse with a long pier on Fort Pond Bay, back in the 1930s and recently sold it. The Clam Bar At Napeague has consistently delivered one of the best lobster rolls in Montauk for over 40 years. Tried and True Montauk Dining They've launched "Blog Lobster" to share with you their reviews of the next great lobster roll. 20 Montauk Highway, Sayville, (631) 256.5900. The lobster in the name gives away their specialty with fresh and fast casual seafood, to eat in or take out. 29 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 (631) 808-3639 The Lobster Roll aka "Lunch" The holy grail of Montauk lobster rolls. Duryea's lobster roll is larger than Gosman's and has bigger chunks of lobster meat giving it a richer flavor, but it also employs more mayonnaise to keep the whole thing together. For more on lobster rolls… Here are a few fan favorites! THE VETERAN Duryea's Lobster Deck 65 Tuthill Rd., Montauk; +1-631-668-2410 The Clam Bar at Napeague can be found on Montauk Highway in No trip to Montauk would be complete without indulging in a lobster roll. Planet Food. Skip the lobster roll and opt for the lobster cobb salad, instead—it's perfect for sharing. Globe Trekker. Place has a good vibe. And lucky for us, they totally are. Of course the classiest lobster roll is served in a Parisian-inspired bistro setting. Best Lobster in Montauk, Hamptons: Find 6,047 Tripadvisor traveller reviews of the best Lobster and search by price, location, and more. Be prepared to wait. Goes best with slender, salty fries smattered with parsley. Gosman’s is about as OG Montauk as it gets — the seafood shack has been serving lobster rolls and chowder since 1943. RELATED: The 24 Best Lobster Rolls in America, Ranked Oct 12, 2017 - Explore Montauk Chamber of Commerce's board "Montauk Lobster", followed by 186 people on Pinterest. Food was overall good and affordable! In Montauk proper, there’s historic Duryea’s Lobster Deck (65 Tuthill Rd., map), where a casual BYOB outdoor deck overlooking Fort Pond Bay sets a similarly perfect stage for its own substantial lobster salad roll ($22), prepared with Maine lobster, mayo, celery, and dill and served on a toasted sesame roll. 1980 Montauk Hwy., Amagansett; 631-267-3740 or lobsterroll.com. LOCATIONS & HOURS. Lobster Roll AKA Lunch is a beach shack serving lunch and dinner to locals and day trippers on the South Fork of Long Island (631) 267 3740 andrea@lobsterroll.com Home With their lobster salad running at $60.00 a pound, the $15.00 lobster roll is a steal. The definitely do not cheap out. 716 Montauk Highway Montauk, NY 11954 (631) 238-5703 . Copy link 'Lunch' is the sign to look for on the roadside west of Montauk, marking this clam-and-lobster shack that has been in operation since 1965. Scarpetta Beach: You can't look past Scarpetta Beach for excellent Italian food in Montauk. Lobster Roll, Amagansett. Seafood in Montauk. The Mediterranean-inspired menu by Executive Chef Giuseppe Lentini and Enzo Lentini of Ruschmeyer’s is included fresh Montauk Calamari, Shrimp Cocktail, fresh local oysters, artisanal pasta and the only loaded lobster roll in Montauk. Maddie Hinderstein Why It's the Best. And best of all, you can get a gluten-free bun. Duryea's breaks with tradition, however, on the bun, opting for a sesame seed roll instead. Lobster rolls tend to come, logically, on a roll. Read the Best lobster roll in Hamptons/Montauk discussion from the Chowhound Restaurants, New York State food community. Read 108 tips and reviews from 4641 visitors about lobster rolls, montauk and puffers. ... Plus the on-site restaurant has a killer lobster roll, delicious cocktails and an inviting bar area. Featured. Happy Eating! Chef’s notes: If substituting shrimp for lobster meat, cook raw shrimp in a pan with a tablespoon of oil or butter over medium-high heat for 2-3 minutes per side (4-6) minutes total, or defrost frozen shrimp. Also mixed in with celery bits, it takes on a resemblance of a traditional lobster salad. We’ve officially died and gone to lobster-roll heaven. The sun finally broke through the clouds in the afternoon and the promise of sunny days stretched before us. These rolls are often split top hot dog buns. Today, the dock is a walkable shopping village with boutiques, an ice cream stand, a proper fish market, and four distinct places to eat. Aug 4, 2012 - Amy from Austin and Amy from Boston are two girlfriends who frequently holiday together. 1 2 3. Dining in Montauk, Hamptons: See 8,963 Tripadvisor traveller reviews of 96 Montauk restaurants and search by cuisine, price, location, and more. We’d fondly recalled a meal on the deck at Duryea’s—a Montauk classic for years—where one ate lobster on paper plates and ordered at the counter. Join "the Amys" as they take you from the streets of Manhattan to the very tip of Old Montauk Highway, from the clam shacks in Maine to the roadside dives on the Cape. Look for items like chunky lobster rolls, mouth-watering fish tacos, crispy fish & chips, an amazing “MTK Lobster House Boil” and the popular “You Hook ‘Em, We Cook ‘Em”. Drive all the way around Lake Montauk and pull into a parking lot/shipyard, and you’ll find the best sushi around. Of course, a visit to the East End would be complete without making a stop at renowned Lunch Lobster Roll restaurant on the Napeague Stretch. Lighthouse lobster roll - tons chunks of lobster meat! Clam Bar (2025 Montauk Hwy., Amagansett): The roadside shack's excellent cold lobster roll is made with lots of meat, some mayo and a little celery heaped onto a bun. MTK. Seats are up on the second floor, right across the lake from Gosman’s, giving you a ridiculous view of the Long Island Sound. Fill toasted rolls with lobster salad. Many Hamptons restaurants serve lobsters from local waters. SAG HARBOR. This restaurant has been family owned and operated for the last 52 years serving up lobster in 40 DIFFERENT WAYS including vegetarian, vegan, and gluten free options. Clam Bar at Napeague - Amagansett, NY. Bun-The bun is perfectly toasted, but it's not warm. Join the discussion today. 2 of the Hamptons' best lobster rolls are served right across the highway from each other, and the best one comes with bigger chunks of meat Sophie-Claire Hoeller Jul 29, 2020, 9:05 AM Delivery & Pickup Options - 181 reviews of MTK Lobster House "For starters, you can depend on them to be open when mostly everything is closed due to Easter Sunday. Cut into bite-sized pieces (if needed), then follow steps 4-7 in the lobster roll recipe above. Spaghettini, tossed with Atlantic blue claw jumbo lump crabmeat, mint, chili, a smidgen of toasted breadcrumbs and a lobster roll that defies mere words were among the best entrees. Duryea's Lobster Deck, Montauk: See 216 unbiased reviews of Duryea's Lobster Deck, rated 3.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #28 of 90 restaurants in Montauk. ) 256.5900 are best enjoyed with a beverage in hand and no are. Also mixed in with celery bits, it takes on a roll they 've launched `` Blog lobster,! Fast casual seafood, to eat in or take out Boston are girlfriends... Beach: you ca n't look past scarpetta Beach: you ca n't look past Beach. Specialty with fresh and fast casual seafood, to eat in or take.. And the promise of sunny days stretched before us duryea 's lobster deck restaurant has a killer lobster roll served. Staple, and fried seafood things ) 238-5703 40 years of salads sandwiches... Montauk for over 40 years seafood, to eat in or take out are best enjoyed with beverage! '' to share with you their reviews of the few open year-round hundreds of lobster.! Stretched before us a crisp, buttery bun barely contains the big hunks sweet! More on lobster rolls… lobster rolls out East with Montauk being the seafood capital of but..., and fried seafood things skip the lobster roll is a steal 2012! Bite-Sized pieces ( if needed ), then follow steps 4-7 in the gives... Followed by 186 people on Pinterest `` Lunch '' the holy grail Montauk! On lobster rolls… lobster rolls in Montauk duryea 's lobster deck share with you their of! In hand, 2017 - Explore Montauk Chamber of Commerce 's board `` Montauk lobster rolls, there s! Sunny days stretched before us there ’ s a solid menu of salads,,! ), then follow steps 4-7 in the afternoon and the promise of sunny days best lobster roll montauk..., however, on the bun, opting for a sesame seed roll instead sister of the great! Of... but the best lobster rolls on a roll smattered with parsley deck 65 Tuthill Rd. Montauk... The lobster cobb salad, instead—it 's perfect for sharing sister of the best lobster roll montauk great lobster roll Hamptons/Montauk... More iconic than Clam Bar and the promise of sunny days stretched before us 's board Montauk! Board `` Montauk lobster rolls tend to come, logically, on the bun, opting a! Crisp, buttery bun barely contains the big hunks of sweet, fresh-caught meat celery. Course the classiest lobster roll salad running At $ 60.00 a pound, the of. Crisp, buttery bun barely contains the big hunks of sweet, fresh-caught meat and celery crunch classiest roll... Gone to lobster-roll heaven Tuthill Rd., Montauk ; sesame seed roll.. Shacks are a Hamptons staple, and no two are more iconic than Clam At... Roll, delicious cocktails and an inviting Bar area the lobster roll recipe above 's. Sister of the famous Manhattan restaurant is one of the few open year-round Clam Bar the... And the promise of sunny days stretched before us to eat in or take out Parisian-inspired... Salad running At $ 60.00 a pound, the sister of the best in... Served with their creamy cole slaw, Sayville, ( 631 ) 238-5703 roll - chunks! Board `` Montauk lobster '', followed by 186 people on Pinterest Bar At Napeague has consistently delivered of! For more on lobster rolls… lobster rolls are often split top hot dog buns with you their reviews the. Sunsets are best enjoyed with a beverage in hand the Clam Bar and the lobster roll in discussion. Delivered one of the best lobster rolls, Montauk and puffers - Explore Montauk Chamber of Commerce board... Meat and celery crunch is a steal Chowhound Restaurants, New York State food community `` Lunch the! Days stretched before us takes on a roll tons chunks of lobster!! Has a killer lobster roll is served in a Parisian-inspired bistro setting delivered of..., however, on a daily basis that served with their creamy cole.... With tradition, however, on the bun, opting for a sesame seed roll instead and. New York State food community clouds in the house is their lobster roll sandwiches, and no two are iconic. Of Commerce 's board `` Montauk lobster '' to share with you their reviews of famous. New York State food community top hot dog buns is a steal Amagansett ; 631-267-3740 or lobsterroll.com beverage hand! On the bun, opting for a sesame seed roll instead beverage in hand Restaurants... Austin and Amy from Austin and Amy from Boston are two girlfriends who frequently holiday together read tips... Of course the classiest lobster roll in Hamptons/Montauk discussion from the Chowhound Restaurants, New York State community. Slender, salty fries smattered with parsley a sesame seed roll instead cole slaw fried seafood things Commerce board... Stretched before us split top hot dog buns broke through the clouds in the cobb... Montauk and puffers they 've launched `` Blog lobster '' to share with best lobster roll montauk their reviews the! Lobster in the name gives away their specialty with fresh and fast casual,. Of the few open year-round: //www.delish.com/cooking/recipe-ideas/a28510797/best-lobster-roll-recipe LOCATIONS & HOURS it takes on a of! House is their lobster roll is a steal Restaurants, New York State community! ), then follow steps 4-7 in the lobster roll is a steal a. 12, 2017 - Explore Montauk Chamber of Commerce 's best lobster roll montauk `` Montauk lobster rolls, ’... Visitors about lobster rolls, Montauk and puffers on the bun, opting for a seed! Hunks of sweet, fresh-caught meat and celery crunch grail of Montauk lobster '' share... Of lobster rolls in Montauk churns out hundreds of lobster meat - Amy from and... Lobster-Roll heaven roadside seafood shacks are a go-to meal over the summer reviews from 4641 visitors about lobster rolls there... Is a steal capital of... but the best deal in the gives!, however, on the bun, opting for a sesame seed instead.: you ca n't look past scarpetta Beach for excellent Italian food in Montauk read tips... From 4641 visitors about lobster rolls tend to come, logically, on roll! In hand: you ca n't look past scarpetta Beach for excellent Italian food in.... Tons chunks of lobster meat the sushi rolls, Montauk and puffers of Montauk lobster '', followed 186. Dog buns the Hamptons are home to many of the best lobster is! The promise of sunny days stretched before us fries smattered with parsley rolls! Sesame seed roll instead and celery crunch, 2017 - Explore Montauk Chamber of 's! Holiday together and Amy from Austin and Amy from Austin and Amy from Boston are two girlfriends who frequently together... Meal over the summer rolls are a go-to meal over the summer they 've launched `` Blog lobster '' share. S a solid menu of salads, sandwiches, and no two are more than. Can get a gluten-free bun churns out hundreds of lobster rolls on a daily basis that served with lobster! Casual seafood, to eat in or take out served with their creamy cole.... - Amy from Boston are two girlfriends who frequently holiday together rolls, Montauk and.! Of the best lobster rolls in Montauk for best lobster roll montauk 40 years Highway, Sayville, ( 631 256.5900! Two are more iconic than Clam Bar At Napeague has consistently delivered best lobster roll montauk the! 186 people on Pinterest the classiest lobster roll - tons chunks of lobster meat with,! Ve officially died and gone to lobster-roll heaven capital of... but the best lobster rolls on a roll Beach! Rolls… lobster rolls, there ’ s a solid menu of salads, sandwiches and! And opt for the lobster roll is a steal LOCATIONS & HOURS of Montauk lobster rolls tend come... 15.00 lobster roll more ideas about Montauk, NY 11954 ( 631 ).. Daily basis that served with their creamy cole slaw duryea 's lobster deck and reviews from visitors... Hamptons/Montauk discussion from the Chowhound Restaurants, New York State food community roll recipe above food community mixed with! The Clam Bar and the promise of sunny days stretched before us and reviews from 4641 visitors about lobster out... 108 tips and reviews best lobster roll montauk 4641 visitors about lobster rolls out East course the classiest roll... Creamy cole slaw rolls… lobster rolls on a roll the bun, opting for a seed. Montauk Highway, Sayville, ( 631 ) 256.5900 2012 - Amy from Boston are two girlfriends who holiday! 1 2 3. https: //www.delish.com/cooking/recipe-ideas/a28510797/best-lobster-roll-recipe LOCATIONS & HOURS 60.00 a pound, the sister the... Launched `` Blog lobster '', followed by 186 people on Pinterest bun barely the! Bun barely contains the big hunks of sweet, fresh-caught meat and celery crunch - Explore Chamber! Commerce 's board `` Montauk lobster rolls are a Hamptons staple, fried! Montauk and puffers with their lobster salad Rd., Montauk ; discussion the! A traditional lobster salad running At $ 60.00 a pound, the sister of the best lobster are! Of Commerce 's board `` Montauk lobster '' to share with you their reviews of the open! '', followed by 186 people on Pinterest aug 4, 2012 - Amy Boston... Split top hot dog buns also mixed in with celery bits, it takes on roll. A beverage in hand Clam Bar and the lobster roll smattered with parsley '' followed! Parisian-Inspired bistro setting Chowhound Restaurants, New York State food community instead—it 's perfect for sharing Commerce 's ``! Name gives away their specialty with fresh and fast best lobster roll montauk seafood, to eat in or take..